New
Week11 · 2026
Starting1
Scoring
New comparison
Toss-up

Smith

WR · PHI vs PIT

Kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ETLimited → Full · hamstring

Projected points11.1pts

First out

Evans

WR · SF vs MIN (Mexico City)

Kickoff Sun 8:20 PM ETDNP → Limited · Achilles

Projected points11.7ptsUsage estimate

Toss-up

Bench

DeVonta Smith or Mike Evans: Who Should I Start in Week 11?

Toss-up. DeVonta Smith gets the nod over Mike Evans.

Confidence
Lower
Mike Evans was limited in practice (achilles)
Started
57%
of leagues

Evans's number is our own estimate because his prop lines aren't posted yet, so this call is less sure than the gap looks.

Tiebreaker

Smith has more of the red zone targets (27% to 18%).

Case for Evans

The case for Evans is an offense expected to score more (25.0 points to 16.8) and surer hands (69% of his targets caught to 63%).

Flips if

Start Mike Evans instead if you need a safe week: he has a safer floor (7.9 to 6.4).

Risk

DeVonta Smith missed his last 3 games. The Week 11 injury report isn't out yet. Mike Evans was limited in practice (achilles): check the inactives, posted about 90 minutes before kickoff. Mike Evans missed his last 3 games (achilles). The Week 11 injury report isn't out yet. Weather in Mike Evans's game: Outdoor · 67F, 5 mph wind, 53% rain. Check it again before kickoff. As of Fri 5:00 AM ET

Highlights

Injuries as of Fri 5:00 AM ET
SmithToss-upWR · PHI vs PITUsually 17.3−6.2pts this week

Helps him

  1. 32%targetsHe sees 32% of PHI’s targets, 4th among WRs.
  2. 10.2per gameHe sees 10.2 targets a game, 4th among WRs.
  3. 87%snapsHe is on the field for 87% of snaps.

Hurts him

  1. 5th toughestper targetGamePIT allows plenty of WR chances because receivers see plenty of targets on them; per target they’re tough (1.65 pts, 5th toughest).
  2. −2.8ptsrec yardsThe consensus has him at 49.5 receiving yards, below his usual 77.5.
EvansFirst outWR · SF vs MIN (Mexico City)Usually 14.8−3.2pts this week

Helps him

  1. 1.2red zoneHe gets 1.2 red zone targets a game, a real path to touchdowns.
  2. 23%targetsHe sees 23% of SF’s targets, 20th among WRs, a steady role.

Hurts him

  1. MINvs WRsGameMIN is the toughest defense for receivers.
  2. 54%snapsHe plays only 54% of snaps, so his work comes in rotation.
  3. −1.5ptspaceFew players at his position keep up numbers like his, so we expect a little less.

Points are how much a reason adds to or takes off his usual week. GameFrom the game around him.

Stat comparison

Every player you picked, stat by stat, most important first.

Stat
Scoring
ProjectionSmith: 11.1Evans: 11.7 (best)
TD pointsof the projectionSmith: 1.6Evans: Our estimate
Expected TDsthis weekSmith: 0.27Evans: Our estimate
Projected team pointsSmith: 16.8Evans: 25.0 (best)
Red zone targetsper gameSmith: 0.8Evans: 1.2 (best)
Role
Snap shareSmith: 87% (best)Evans: 54%
Usage worthptsSmith: 17.7 (best)Evans: 12.3
Target shareSmith: 32% (best)Evans: 23%
Targets / gameSmith: 10.3 (best)Evans: 6.5
Air yards shareSmith: 48% (best)Evans: 43%
Receiving TDs vs RZ targetsSmith: AboveEvans: Above
WOPRSmith: 0.81 (best)Evans: 0.64
RZ target shareSmith: 27% (best)Evans: 18%
Catch rateSmith: 63%Evans: 69% (best)
SeparationSmith: 2.4 yds (best)Evans: 1.8 yds
YAC over expectedSmith: +0.3Evans: +1.0 (best)
Usage worth vs scoredSmith: Earned by usage 17.7Scored 17.3Evans: Earned by usage 12.3Scored 14.8
Vacated targets this weekSmith: 0.0Evans: 0.0
Inside 10 target shareSmith: 33% (best)Evans: 18%
Range
FloorSmith: 6.4Evans: 7.9 (best)
CeilingSmith: 18.4 (best)Evans: 17.5
Points from TDssteadier when lowerSmith: 17%Evans: 20%
Big weeks (20+ pts)Smith: 29% (best)Evans: 17%
Dud weeks (under 7 pts)lower is betterSmith: 8%Evans: 0% (best)
SteadinessSmith: Steady±8.4 ptsEvans: Very steady (best)±6.2 pts · 6 games
Matchup
Matchup gradevs his position · 2026, 9 gmSmith: C+ (best)Evans: F
Game scriptSmith: Expected to trailEvans: Expected to lead (best)
Opp takeaways / gamelower is betterSmith: 1.4 (best)Evans: 1.9
Defense funnelSmith: NeutralEvans: Neutral
Opp pass yds allowedSmith: 29th (soft) (best)Evans: 2nd (tough)
Starting QBSmith: Milton (Active)Evans: Purdy (Active)
Opp defender outSmith: Queen (LB)Evans: Richter (LB)
WeatherSmith: No concernEvans: Outdoor67F, 5 mph wind, 53% rain
Roof / surfacegrassSmith: OpenEvans: Open
Rest / scheduleSmith: Off a byeEvans: Normal
Opp paceSmith: 13th (average) (best)Evans: 30th (slow)
Opp deep targets allowed / gameSmith: 3.1 (best)14th (average)Evans: 2.22nd (tough)
Opp catch rate allowedSmith: 63% (best)19th (average)Evans: 61%16th (average)
Form
Last 3 avgSmith: 20.2 (best)Evans: 17.1
Last 5 avgSmith: 17.3 (best)Evans: 14.4
vs seasonSmith: +3.0 (best)Evans: +2.3 (Rising)
Yards per route runSmith: 2.52Evans: 4.08 (best)
Receiving aDOTSmith: 12.2Evans: 14.6
Target share trendSmith: SteadyEvans: Steady
Games since injurySmith: 0Evans: 0
Crowd
Started in leaguesSmith: 58% (best)Evans: 46%
Nuvela position ranklower is betterSmith: WR23Evans: WR20 (best)
Consensus yardsreceivingSmith: 49.5Evans: Our estimate

Deciding on someone else?

Choose 2 to 5 players for any week.

Sit or start?