New
Week11 · 2026
Starting1
Scoring
Pass TD
New comparison
Toss-up

Herbert

QB · LAC vs NYJ

Kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET

Projected points16.1pts

First out

McCarthy

QB · NYG vs JAX

Kickoff Sun 4:25 PM ET

Projected points16.2pts

Toss-up

Bench

J.J. McCarthy or Justin Herbert: Who Should I Start in Week 11?

Toss-up. Justin Herbert gets the nod over J.J. McCarthy.

Confidence
Lower
Toss-up
Started
50%
of leagues

Tiebreaker

Herbert has more chances to throw (35.0 a game to 23.4).

Case for McCarthy

The case for McCarthy is fewer interceptions (1.9% of his throws to 4.3%) and more upside (a ceiling of 21.7 to 20.6).

Flips if

Start J.J. McCarthy instead if you want fewer interceptions (1.9% of his throws to 4.3%).

Risk

The risk: McCarthy threw for 293 yards and a touchdown, and ran for 34 last week (17.1 points).

Highlights

Injuries as of Fri 5:00 AM ET
HerbertToss-upQB · LAC vs NYJUsually 10.8+5.3pts this week

Helps him

  1. 16.3last weekHe threw for 129 yards without a touchdown but ran for 51 and a touchdown last week (16.3 points).
  2. OutOnyemataGameHe faces a Jets defense without defensive tackle David Onyemata.
  3. +3.3ptspass TDsThe consensus has him at 1.50 passing TDs, above his usual 0.67.

Hurts him

  1. 6th softestper passGameNYJ allows few QB chances because teams throw little against them; per pass they’re soft (0.63 pts, 6th softest).
  2. 12.9floorA quiet week could drop to about 12.9 points.
  3. 4.3%INT rateHe throws an interception on 4.3% of his passes.
McCarthyFirst outQB · NYG vs JAXUsually 10.2+6.0pts this week

Helps him

  1. 17.1last weekHe threw for 293 yards and a touchdown, and ran for 34 last week (17.1 points).
  2. +4.4ptspass TDsThe consensus has him at 1.50 passing TDs, above his usual 0.40.

Hurts him

  1. JAXvs QBsGameJAX is the 4th toughest defense for quarterbacks.
  2. 26%pressureGameThe JAX pass rush gets pressure on 26% of dropbacks.
  3. 12.3floorA quiet week could drop to about 12.3 points.

Points are how much a reason adds to or takes off his usual week. GameFrom the game around him.

Stat comparison

Every player you picked, stat by stat, most important first.

Stat
Scoring
ProjectionHerbert: 16.1McCarthy: 16.2 (best)
Rush TD pointsof the projectionHerbert: 1.4 (best)McCarthy: 1.2
Rush TDs expectedthis weekHerbert: 0.24 (best)McCarthy: 0.20
Projected team pointsHerbert: 22.5 (best)McCarthy: 20.3
Goal line carriesper gameHerbert: 0.2 (best)McCarthy: 0.0
Red zone carriesper gameHerbert: 0.7 (best)McCarthy: 0.2
Pass attempts / gameHerbert: 28.1 (best)McCarthy: 20.8
Role
Snap shareHerbert: 98% (best)McCarthy: 62%
Touch shareHerbert: 10% (best)McCarthy: 6%
Touches / gameHerbert: 4.6 (best)McCarthy: 3.0
Yards per attemptHerbert: 6.8McCarthy: 8.8 (best)
Pass TD rateHerbert: 2%McCarthy: 2%
Rush yards / gameHerbert: 26.8 (best)McCarthy: 17.0
Points from rushingHerbert: 31%McCarthy: 17%
Rushing points / gameHerbert: 3.3 pts / game (best)McCarthy: 1.7 pts / game
Rushing floorHerbert: 2.4 pts / game (best)McCarthy: 1.2 pts / game
Designed runs / gameHerbert: 1.2McCarthy: 1.4 (best)
Scrambles / gameHerbert: 3.3 (best)McCarthy: 1.2
Dropbacks / gameHerbert: 35.0 (best)McCarthy: 23.4
Designed runs inside the 10 / gameHerbert: 0.2 (best)McCarthy: 0.0
Sacks per dropbackHerbert: 10%McCarthy: 9% (best)
INT rateHerbert: 4.3%McCarthy: 1.9% (best)
Pass aDOTHerbert: 7.5McCarthy: 9.8
High value touches / gameHerbert: 0.6 (best)McCarthy: 0.0
Goal line carry shareHerbert: 29% (best)McCarthy: 0%
Red zone touches / gameHerbert: 0.8 (best)McCarthy: 0.2
Rush success rateHerbert: 46% (best)McCarthy: 38%
Breakaway rate (20+ yd runs)Herbert: 7.3%McCarthy: 7.7% (best)
Range
FloorHerbert: 12.9 (best)McCarthy: 12.3
CeilingHerbert: 20.6McCarthy: 21.7 (best)
Points from TDssteadier when lowerHerbert: 6%McCarthy: 0%
Big weeks (25+ pts)Herbert: 0%McCarthy: 0%
Dud weeks (under 12 pts)lower is betterHerbert: 67%McCarthy: 50% (best)
SteadinessHerbert: Very steady (best)±2.8 ptsMcCarthy: Very steady±4.8 pts · 4 games
Matchup
Matchup gradevs his positionHerbert: B- (best)2026, 10 gmMcCarthy: D+2026, 9 gm
Game scriptHerbert: Expected to lead (best)McCarthy: Expected to trail
Opp takeaways / gamelower is betterHerbert: 1.2 (best)McCarthy: 1.8
Defense funnelHerbert: NeutralMcCarthy: Neutral
Opp pass yds allowedHerbert: 5th (tough)McCarthy: 17th (average) (best)
Opp sacks / gameHerbert: 2.3McCarthy: 1.8 (best)
Opp defender outHerbert: Onyemata (DT)McCarthy: None listed
Roof / surfaceturfHerbert: DomeMcCarthy: Open
Rest / scheduleHerbert: NormalMcCarthy: 10 days rest
Opp paceHerbert: 25th (slow)McCarthy: 24th (slow) (best)
Opp pressure rateHerbert: 21% (best)15th (average)McCarthy: 26%7th (tough)
Pressure facedHerbert: 26%McCarthy: 19% (best)
Opp rush yds allowedHerbert: 30th (soft) (best)McCarthy: 6th (tough)
Opp stuff rateHerbert: 14% (best)31st (soft)McCarthy: 18%13th (average)
Opp yards per carry allowedHerbert: 4.6 (best)23rd (soft)McCarthy: 4.08th (tough)
Opp deep targets allowed / gameHerbert: 2.62nd (tough)McCarthy: 3.1 (best)9th (tough)
Opp catch rate allowedHerbert: 67%15th (average)McCarthy: 70% (best)27th (soft)
Form
Last 3 avgHerbert: 11.5McCarthy: 11.5
Last 5 avgHerbert: 10.7 (best)McCarthy: 10.2
vs seasonHerbert: +0.7 (Steady)McCarthy: +1.3 (Rising) (best)
Yards per carryHerbert: 5.9 (best)McCarthy: 5.7
Carries / gameHerbert: 4.6 (best)McCarthy: 3.0
Pass volume trendHerbert: CoolingMcCarthy: Steady
Crowd
Started in leaguesHerbert: 51% (best)McCarthy: 42%
Nuvela position ranklower is betterHerbert: QB14McCarthy: QB13 (best)
Consensus yardspassingHerbert: 204.5McCarthy: 217.5 (best)

Deciding on someone else?

Choose 2 to 5 players for any week.

Sit or start?