New
Week11 · 2026
Starting1
Scoring
New comparison
Start

Taylor

RB · IND @ HOU

FinalHOU 26 – 3 IND

Final points6.7pts

projected 14.4

First out

Montgomery

RB · HOU vs IND

FinalHOU 26 – 3 IND

Final points15.4pts

projected 13.1

David Montgomery or Jonathan Taylor: Who Should I Start in Week 11?

FinalWeek 11 result

Nuvela’s call

We started Jonathan Taylor over David Montgomery.

PlayerProjectedActual
Taylor Start14.46.7
Montgomery First out13.115.4

David Montgomery outscored Jonathan Taylor 15.4 to 6.7.

Highlights

Injuries as of Fri 5:00 AM ET
TaylorStartRB · IND @ HOUUsually 16.6−2.2pts this week

Helps him

  1. 1.6inside the 5He averages 1.6 carries a game inside the 5, so touchdowns stay in reach.
  2. 43%touchesHe handles 43% of IND’s touches (7th among RBs in touches a game), the most in his backfield.
  3. 40%big weeks40% of his games have been big weeks.

Hurts him

  1. 16touchesHe’s had 16 touches a game over his last 3, down from 20.5.
  2. −7.1last 3 vs avgHis last three games run 7.1 points below his season average.
  3. −2.2ptsrush yardsThe consensus has him at 51.5 rushing yards, below his usual 73.9.
MontgomeryFirst outRB · HOU vs INDUsually 11.1+2.0pts this week

Helps him

  1. INDvs RBsGameIND is the 4th softest defense for running backs.
  2. +2.5ptsrush yardsThe consensus has him at 56.5 rushing yards, above his usual 31.8.

Hurts him

  1. 7.0floorA quiet week could drop to about 7.0 points.

Points are how much a reason adds to or takes off his usual week. GameFrom the game around him.

Stat comparison

Every player you picked, stat by stat, most important first.

Stat
Scoring
ProjectionTaylor: 14.4 (best)Montgomery: 13.1
TD pointsof the projectionTaylor: 3.4Montgomery: 4.9 (best)
Expected TDsthis weekTaylor: 0.56Montgomery: 0.82 (best)
Projected team pointsTaylor: 16.0Montgomery: 28.5 (best)
Goal line carriesper gameTaylor: 1.6 (best)Montgomery: 0.6
Red zone carriesper gameTaylor: 3.4 (best)Montgomery: 1.8
Red zone targetsper gameTaylor: 0.2Montgomery: 0.2
Role
Snap shareTaylor: 76% (best)Montgomery: 47%
Usage worthptsTaylor: 17.9 (best)Montgomery: 8.6
Touch shareTaylor: 43% (best)Montgomery: 25%
Target shareTaylor: 14% (best)Montgomery: 4%
Touches / gameTaylor: 20.5 (best)Montgomery: 11.8
Targets / gameTaylor: 4.0 (best)Montgomery: 1.4
Air yards shareTaylor: Behind the lineMontgomery: 2%
Vacated touches this weekTaylor: 0.0Montgomery: 21.3 (best)
High value touches / gameTaylor: 4.8 (best)Montgomery: 2.4
Goal line carry shareTaylor: 76% (best)Montgomery: 50%
Red zone touches / gameTaylor: 3.6 (best)Montgomery: 2.0
Rush success rateTaylor: 42% (best)Montgomery: 25%
Breakaway rate (20+ yd runs)Taylor: 2.8% (best)Montgomery: 0%
Usage worth vs scoredTaylor: Earned by usage 17.9Scored 16.6Montgomery: Earned by usage 8.6Scored 9.1
Rush yards / gameTaylor: 73.9 (best)Montgomery: 27.6
Points from rushingTaylor: 73%Montgomery: 57%
WOPRTaylor: 0.18 (best)Montgomery: 0.07
RZ target shareTaylor: 8% (best)Montgomery: 6%
Inside 10 target shareTaylor: 8%Montgomery: 25% (best)
Catch rateTaylor: 70%Montgomery: 100% (best)
Rushing points / gameTaylor: 12.2 pts / game (best)Montgomery: 5.2 pts / game
Rushing floorTaylor: 9.5 pts / game (best)Montgomery: 3.2 pts / game
Range
FloorTaylor: 9.0 (best)Montgomery: 7.0
CeilingTaylor: 21.6 (best)Montgomery: 21.0
Points from TDssteadier when lowerTaylor: 29%Montgomery: 40%
Big weeks (20+ pts)Taylor: 40% (best)Montgomery: 25%
Dud weeks (under 8 pts)lower is betterTaylor: 10% (best)Montgomery: 75%
SteadinessTaylor: Very steady (best)±7.8 ptsMontgomery: Volatile±11.9 pts · 4 games
Matchup
Matchup gradevs his positionTaylor: C+2026, 9 gmMontgomery: A- (best)2026, 10 gm
Game scriptTaylor: Expected to trailMontgomery: Expected to lead (best)
Opp takeaways / gamelower is betterTaylor: 1.0Montgomery: 0.7 (best)
Defense funnelTaylor: NeutralMontgomery: Neutral
Opp rush yds allowedTaylor: 11th (average)Montgomery: 29th (soft) (best)
Backfield roleTaylor: LeadMontgomery: Lead
Opp defender outTaylor: Hunter (DE)Montgomery: Ward (CB)
Roof / surfaceturfTaylor: Retractable roofMontgomery: Retractable roof
Rest / scheduleTaylor: Short week (4d)Montgomery: Short week (4d)
Opp paceTaylor: 13th (average)Montgomery: 9th (fast) (best)
Opp stuff rateTaylor: 14% (best)30th (soft)Montgomery: 15%25th (soft)
Opp yards per carry allowedTaylor: 4.114th (average)Montgomery: 4.6 (best)28th (soft)
Opp pass yds allowedTaylor: 30th (soft) (best)Montgomery: 18th (average)
Opp deep targets allowed / game1st (tough)Taylor: 0.0Montgomery: 0.0
Opp catch rate allowedTaylor: 76% (best)13th (average)Montgomery: 72%8th (tough)
Starting QBTaylor: Jones (Active)Montgomery: Stroud (Active)
Form
Last 3 avgTaylor: 9.5 (best)Montgomery: 4.1
Last 5 avgTaylor: 13.7 (best)Montgomery: 9.1
vs seasonTaylor: −7.1 (Cooling)Montgomery: −5.0 (Cooling) (best)
Yards per carryTaylor: 4.2 (best)Montgomery: 2.7
Carries / gameTaylor: 17.7 (best)Montgomery: 10.4
Yards per route runTaylor: 1.17 (best)Montgomery: 1.08
Receiving aDOTTaylor: −1.4Montgomery: 3.6
Touch share trendTaylor: SteadyMontgomery: Left Week 5 hurt
Games since injuryTaylor: None recentlyMontgomery: 0
Crowd
Started in leaguesTaylor: 96% (best)Montgomery: 60%
Nuvela position ranklower is betterTaylor: RB14 (best)Montgomery: RB17
Consensus yardsrushingTaylor: 51.5Montgomery: 56.5 (best)

Deciding on someone else?

Choose 2 to 5 players for any week.

Sit or start?