New
Week11 · 2026
Starting1
Scoring
Pass TD
New comparison
Toss-up

McCarthy

QB · NYG vs JAX

Kickoff Sun 4:25 PM ET

Projected points16.2pts

First out

Smith

QB · NYJ @ LAC

Kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ETLatest report: Limited · Ankle

Projected points14.5pts

Toss-up

Bench

Geno Smith or J.J. McCarthy: Who Should I Start in Week 11?

Toss-up. J.J. McCarthy gets the nod over Geno Smith.

Ahead by
+1.7pts
over Smith
Confidence
Lower
Geno Smith was limited in practice (ankle)
Started
41%
of leagues

Edge

J.J. McCarthy projects 1.7 more than Geno Smith.

Flips if

Start Geno Smith instead if you need a big week: he has more big weeks (10% of his games to 0%).

Risk

Geno Smith was limited in practice (ankle): check the inactives, posted about 90 minutes before kickoff. As of Fri 5:00 AM ET

Highlights

Injuries as of Fri 5:00 AM ET
McCarthyToss-upQB · NYG vs JAXUsually 10.2+6.0pts this week

Helps him

  1. 17.1last weekHe threw for 293 yards and a touchdown, and ran for 34 last week (17.1 points).
  2. OutGreenGameHe faces a Jaguars defense without defensive end BJ Green II.
  3. +4.4ptspass TDsThe consensus has him at 1.50 passing TDs, above his usual 0.40.

Hurts him

  1. JAXvs QBsGameJAX is the 4th toughest defense for quarterbacks.
  2. 26%pressureGameThe JAX pass rush gets pressure on 26% of dropbacks.
  3. 12.3floorA quiet week could drop to about 12.3 points.
SmithFirst outQB · NYJ @ LACUsually 14.5+0.0pts this week

Helps him

  1. 21.4ceilingHis best weeks reach about 21.4 points.
  2. 10.2floorA quiet week still projects to about 10.2 points.
  3. +0.7ptspass TDsThe consensus has him at 1.50 passing TDs, above his usual 1.33.

Hurts him

  1. LACvs QBsGameLAC is the 6th toughest defense for quarterbacks.
  2. 10.2floorA quiet week could drop to about 10.2 points.
  3. 60%dud weeks60% of his games have been dud weeks.

Points are how much a reason adds to or takes off his usual week. GameFrom the game around him.

Stat comparison

Every player you picked, stat by stat, most important first.

Stat
Scoring
ProjectionMcCarthy: 16.2 (best)Smith: 14.5
Rush TD pointsof the projectionMcCarthy: 1.2 (best)Smith: 0.4
Rush TDs expectedthis weekMcCarthy: 0.20 (best)Smith: 0.07
Projected team pointsMcCarthy: 20.3 (best)Smith: 19.5
Goal line carriesper gameMcCarthy: 0.0Smith: 0.0
Red zone carriesper gameMcCarthy: 0.2Smith: 0.2
Pass attempts / gameMcCarthy: 20.8Smith: 29.2 (best)
Role
Snap shareMcCarthy: 62%Smith: 95% (best)
Touch shareMcCarthy: 6% (best)Smith: 5%
Touches / gameMcCarthy: 3.0 (best)Smith: 2.4
Yards per attemptMcCarthy: 8.8 (best)Smith: 7.6
Pass TD rateMcCarthy: 2%Smith: 4% (best)
Rush yards / gameMcCarthy: 17.0 (best)Smith: 5.4
Points from rushingMcCarthy: 17%Smith: 4%
Rushing points / gameMcCarthy: 1.7 pts / game (best)Smith: 0.5 pts / game
Rushing floorMcCarthy: 1.2 pts / game (best)Smith: 0.4 pts / game
Designed runs / gameMcCarthy: 1.4 (best)Smith: 0.5
Scrambles / gameMcCarthy: 1.2Smith: 1.2
Dropbacks / gameMcCarthy: 23.4Smith: 33.5 (best)
Designed runs inside the 10 / gameMcCarthy: 0.0Smith: 0.0
Sacks per dropbackMcCarthy: 9%Smith: 9%
INT rateMcCarthy: 1.9%Smith: 1.0% (best)
Pass aDOTMcCarthy: 9.8Smith: 7.5
High value touches / gameMcCarthy: 0.0Smith: 0.0
Goal line carry shareMcCarthy: 0%Smith: 0%
Red zone touches / gameMcCarthy: 0.2Smith: 0.2
Rush success rateMcCarthy: 38%Smith: 59% (best)
Breakaway rate (20+ yd runs)McCarthy: 7.7% (best)Smith: 0%
Range
FloorMcCarthy: 12.3 (best)Smith: 10.2
CeilingMcCarthy: 21.7 (best)Smith: 21.4
Points from TDssteadier when lowerMcCarthy: 0%Smith: 0%
Big weeks (25+ pts)McCarthy: 0%Smith: 10% (best)
Dud weeks (under 12 pts)lower is betterMcCarthy: 50% (best)Smith: 60%
SteadinessMcCarthy: Very steady (best)±4.8 pts · 4 gamesSmith: Steady±6.9 pts
Matchup
Matchup gradevs his position · 2026, 9 gmMcCarthy: D+Smith: D+
Game scriptMcCarthy: Expected to trailSmith: Expected to trail (best)
Opp takeaways / gamelower is betterMcCarthy: 1.8Smith: 1.6 (best)
Defense funnelMcCarthy: NeutralSmith: Neutral
Opp pass yds allowedMcCarthy: 17th (average)Smith: 20th (average) (best)
Opp sacks / gameMcCarthy: 1.8Smith: 1.7 (best)
Opp defender outMcCarthy: Green (DE)Smith: None listed
Roof / surfaceturfMcCarthy: OpenSmith: Dome
Rest / scheduleMcCarthy: 10 days restSmith: Normal
Opp paceMcCarthy: 24th (slow)Smith: 16th (average) (best)
Opp pressure rateMcCarthy: 26%7th (tough)Smith: 19% (best)23rd (soft)
Pressure facedMcCarthy: 19% (best)Smith: 24%
Opp rush yds allowedMcCarthy: 6th (tough)Smith: 15th (average) (best)
Opp stuff rateMcCarthy: 18%13th (average)Smith: 15% (best)24th (soft)
Opp yards per carry allowedMcCarthy: 4.08th (tough)Smith: 4.2 (best)13th (average)
Opp deep targets allowed / gameMcCarthy: 3.1 (best)9th (tough)Smith: 3.05th (tough)
Opp catch rate allowedMcCarthy: 70% (best)27th (soft)Smith: 68%20th (average)
Form
Last 3 avgMcCarthy: 11.5 (best)Smith: 10.4
Last 5 avgMcCarthy: 10.2Smith: 13.4 (best)
vs seasonMcCarthy: +1.3 (Rising) (best)Smith: −3.2 (Cooling)
Yards per carryMcCarthy: 5.7 (best)Smith: 2.3
Carries / gameMcCarthy: 3.0 (best)Smith: 2.4
Pass volume trendMcCarthy: SteadySmith: Left Week 10 hurt
Crowd
Started in leaguesMcCarthy: 42%Smith: Not widely started
Nuvela position ranklower is betterMcCarthy: QB13 (best)Smith: QB19
Consensus yardspassingMcCarthy: 217.5Smith: 218.5 (best)

Deciding on someone else?

Choose 2 to 5 players for any week.

Sit or start?