How Sit or Start works
Sit or Start answers one fantasy football question: of the players you are choosing between this week, who goes in your lineup? You add two to five NFL players, and each one gets a Start or Bench call for this week, with the numbers behind it. This page explains where those numbers come from and what each one means.
The call: Start or Bench
Every player you add is ranked by his projected fantasy points for this week in your scoring format. You tell the page how many lineup spots you are filling (one by default). The players with the highest projections fill those spots and are marked Start; everyone else is marked Bench. The line between the two groups is the start line, and the best player below it is the first one out. The page says how many points the start is clear of the first one out.
Below the call, each comparison shows the matchup, the posted game lines for each game, recent scoring and usage, plus a short list of what helps and what hurts each player this week.
The projection
The projection is the fantasy points we expect from a player this week, in your scoring format, to one decimal place. When player lines are posted for his game, it is built from the consensus of those posted player lines, turned into fantasy points for your format. When no line is posted for him yet, it is Nuvela's own estimate, built from his usage: his share of his team's carries, targets or pass attempts. Each player card says which of the two it is. A player ruled out gets no projection.
A player whose status is in doubt gets a chance to play and a number for when he plays through it, both measured from past Questionable players with the same practice report on the same day of the week, and moved by the news (for example “expected to play”). Below 90% to play, his projection is his number if active, with his chance to play beside it. When he changes who starts, the call is written as a plan: who to start if he is active, and who if he sits.
| Report | Practice | Plays | Points if active | Past cases |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fri | Did not practice | 48% | 85% | 63 |
| Fri | Limited | 66% | 95% | 309 |
| Fri | Full | 88% | 100% | 84 |
| Fri | No report | 64% | 86% | 14 |
| Wed | Did not practice | 52% | 85% | 11 |
| Wed | Limited | 76% | 100% | 15 |
| Wed | Full | 88% | 100% | 1 |
| Wed | No report | 65% | 90% | 128 |
| Thu | Did not practice | 46% | 85% | 31 |
| Thu | Limited | 81% | 100% | 41 |
| Thu | Full | 88% | 100% | 15 |
| Thu | No report | 52% | 85% | 37 |
Floor and ceiling
The floor and ceiling start from this week's projection. From his last 16 games we measure how far his 30th percentile game sits below his average and how far his 85th percentile game sits above it, lean those on his position's usual spread when he has few games, and apply them to the projection. The floor is never more than 85% of the projection and the ceiling never less than 115% of it.
Last season's games are used only until a player has 8 games this season, weighted less as this season's games come in, and never for a player who has changed team or role.
Together they show the range a normal week falls in: a narrow range is a steadier play, a wide one a riskier one. They are not a guarantee: a player can score under his floor or over his ceiling.
Confidence in the call
Each call carries one tier. It starts from the projection gap between your last starter and your first bench player.
- Under 1 point is a Toss-up.
- 1 to just under 3 is a Lean.
- 3 to just under 6 is a Start.
- 6 or more is an Easy call.
Each of these drops the tier one step.
- The benched player wins at least 2 more of the stats that decide it than the started player.
- The two projections come from different sources; one is a Nuvela estimate.
- Either player is listed Questionable or Doubtful, or is under 90% to play.
- Either player has under 3 games this season and no sample from last season.
And these always hold.
- All of these together move a call down one step at most.
- A gap of 3 points or more is never a toss-up.
- In a toss-up, the player who wins more of the stats that decide it gets the nod. Level on those, it is put as safe against upside. Level on that too, the higher floor gets it.
- When a player is under 90% to play and changes who starts, the call is a plan: start him if he's active, and who to start if he sits.
- When the start may not play and nobody can be swapped in once his inactives post, the call is at most a Lean, and a toss-up when he is under 50% to play, whatever the gap.
The chip on the verdict reads High for an Easy call or a Start. It reads Moderate for a Lean and Lower for a Toss-up. A plan, when a player may not play, reads Depends on inactives. It rates the decision, not how often we are right. Each player card shows his own range instead: tight, normal or wide.
Key stats
The first table on a comparison shows the three to five numbers that decide a call at that position: for example a quarterback's rushing floor and dropbacks, a running back's high value touches and goal line share, a receiver's target and air yards share, a kicker's field goal volume, or the offense a defense faces. Projection and range always come first; the rest are the rows where the players differ most. The better value is in blue, and a tie highlights no one. A small chip marks a value that rests on last season or on only one or two games. The other tabs keep every number.
A usage rate from too small a sample is shown with its game count but never decides a call. The minimum is QB 60 dropbacks, RB 30 touches, WR 20 targets and TE 20 targets.
Why this call
Under the verdict, the page explains the call in a fixed order: the call with its confidence and margin, the one number that decides it, what the benched player does better and why the call still stands, what would flip it, and anything to check before kickoff, such as the final injury report, the inactives (posted about 90 minutes before kickoff) or the weather. It is written from the numbers on the page by fixed rules.
Safe and Upside
On a close call before kickoff, you can reorder the players when that changes the order: by their floor (Safe), or by their Big weeks row (Upside). Upside uses their ceiling when a player has no such row. The Start or Bench call itself stays on the projection.
Results: Hit, Miss or Push
Once the games are final, each player shows his final fantasy points, and the verdict grades our call: a Hit when the player we started outscored the first player we benched, a Miss when he did not, and a Push when they finished less than one point apart. Before Week 6 of 2026 the line was half a point.
Passing touchdowns
Projections count a passing touchdown as 4 points by default. When a quarterback is in the comparison, a Pass TD switch rescores his projection, floor, ceiling and past games at 6 points per passing touchdown. Other positions are not affected.
When there is no call
A player gets no Start or Bench call when there is no projection for him this week (usually because he has too little recent usage to estimate from) or when he is ruled out. A player on a bye is marked BYE. If none of the players you added has a projection, the page says there is not enough data to make a call rather than guessing. Once a game kicks off, its players are marked LIVE or FINAL instead of getting a call, because the lineup decision has passed.
Scoring formats
Sit or Start supports PPR (one point per reception), Half PPR (half a point) and Standard (no points for receptions), with PPR the default. Changing the format changes the value of a catch, so the projections of pass catchers move, and the ranking and the call can change with them. A quarterback's projection does not depend on receptions.
How fresh the numbers are
Each comparison is rebuilt from Nuvela's NFL data service once every 5 minutes from Thursday to Monday and once an hour on other days, and sooner when a projection, injury report or the consensus numbers change. Injury and practice report items are summarised in one line with their date, and an injury designation with the time it was reported when the data carries one.
What the numbers do not say
The recent form section shows up to 5 of his most recent fantasy scores, each labelled with its week; games from last season are marked with the year. Early in a season some rates still lean on the previous season, and the page says so when they do. Projected team points and the expected game script are inputs, not Nuvela models. Sit or Start is for setting fantasy lineups.
How to read these numbers
- Projection
- His expected fantasy points this week in your scoring format. When outside player projections are out for his game, it is built from their consensus. Until then, it is Nuvela’s own estimate from his usage. It is then adjusted for availability: a player ruled out gets no projection, and one whose status is in doubt is shown at his number if he plays, with his chance to play beside it. A player at 90% or more to play keeps a small discount for the chance he sits.
- Floor
- A bad week for him this week: his projection scaled by how far his own 30th percentile game sits below his average. That ratio is blended with a typical one for his position, and his own games count for more the more he has (half the weight at 8 games). Under 4 games the typical ratio stands alone. For a QB, RB, WR or TE it is never more than 85% of his projection. A kicker or defense has no typical ratio, so its floor is its own 30th percentile game. Last season’s games fill in only while he has few games this season, and never after a change of team or role.
- Ceiling
- His upside this week: his projection scaled by how far his own 85th percentile game sits above his average, blended with a typical ratio for his position the same way as the floor. For a QB, RB, WR or TE it is never less than 115% of his projection. It uses the same games as the floor. A kicker or defense gets its own 85th percentile game.
- Usage worth (pts)
- What his per game workload is worth at league average efficiency: each carry and target valued at a typical player’s rate for your scoring format, before any skill of his own.
- Matchup grade
- How many fantasy points this defense allows to his position in your scoring format, against what those same offenses usually score, ranked across all 32 defenses. Early in the season it blends this season with last season. A+ is the softest matchup for his position and F the toughest.
- Projected team points
- The points his team is expected to score this week. More team points means more chances for him to score.
- Last 3 vs season
- The number is his average over his last three games minus his average over all his games this season. The word compares his last three games with the games before them, in PPR points: 15% or more higher is Rising, 15% or more lower is Cooling, otherwise Steady. The word needs at least 5 games, so early in the season the number can show alone. With exactly 3 games only the word shows, comparing his latest game with the two before it.
- Touch share trend
- Which way his share of his team’s carries and catches has moved over his last three games. Rising when it went up in each game and ends at least 15% above where it started, Cooling when it went down in each game and ends at least 15% below, otherwise Steady. A game he left hurt is skipped.
- Target share trend
- Which way his share of his team’s targets has moved over his last three games. Rising when it went up in each game and ends at least 15% above where it started, Cooling when it went down in each game and ends at least 15% below, otherwise Steady. A game he left hurt is skipped.
- Pass volume trend
- Which way his dropbacks have moved over his last three games. Rising when it went up in each game and ends at least 15% above where it started, Cooling when it went down in each game and ends at least 15% below, otherwise Steady. A game he left hurt is skipped.
- Steadiness
- How much his weekly points swing around his own average. The number is his typical swing in points. The word compares that swing with his average: up to half of it is Very steady, up to 65% Steady, up to 85% Up & down, and more is Volatile. So a high scorer can swing more points and still read steady. A defense shows the swing alone, without a word, since its points often sit near zero. Needs at least 4 games. Counted over his last 16 games at most: this season’s, with last season’s latest games filling in, at a lower weight, until he has 8 this season, and never after a change of team or role. A defense uses this season’s games only.
- Big weeks
- The share of his games with a big score for his position: 25+ points for a QB, 20+ for a RB or WR, 15+ for a TE in PPR. Half PPR uses 85% of these and Standard 70%. The threshold is printed in the row. Counted over his last 16 games at most: this season’s, with last season’s latest games filling in, at a lower weight, until he has 8 this season, and never after a change of team or role. A defense uses this season’s games only.
- Dud weeks
- The share of his games with a dud score for his position: under 12 points for a QB, 8 for a RB, 7 for a WR, 5 for a TE in PPR. Half PPR uses 85% of these and Standard 70%. The threshold is printed in the row. Counted over his last 16 games at most: this season’s, with last season’s latest games filling in, at a lower weight, until he has 8 this season, and never after a change of team or role. A defense uses this season’s games only.
- Receiving TDs vs RZ targets
- His receiving touchdowns compared with what his red zone targets usually produce: Above, In line or Below. Shown only once he has at least 3 red zone targets.
- Vacated touches and targets
- Vacated touches: carries and targets left by his team’s running backs who are out, doubtful, on IR or on another reserve list this week. Vacated targets: targets left by his team’s receivers and tight ends who are. Each at their per game rate this season.
- Defense funnel
- Whether the opponent’s run defense and pass defense are far enough apart to push offenses one way. A small gap reads Neutral.
- Game script
- Whether his team is expected to be ahead, level or behind this week: Expected to lead, Close game or Expected to trail.
- Rushing floor
- Points his running gives him in a quiet week: a low week of rushing yards plus a steady share of rushing touchdowns, steadied toward the league rate for his position.
- Rushing points / game
- The fantasy points a game he scores with his legs alone: 1 point per 10 rushing yards plus 6 per rushing touchdown, the same in every scoring format. Counted over his games this season.
- Routes run %
- Share of his team’s dropbacks where he ran a route, from this season’s games.
- Points from touchdowns
- The share of his fantasy points that came from touchdowns. A high share makes his weeks swing on whether he scores. Counted over his games this season.
- Opp red zone TD rate allowed
- The share of red zone trips against this week’s opponent that end in a touchdown. A low rate means more drives stall into field goal tries, the soft spot for a kicker.
- Designed runs / game
- Runs called for him, not scrambles after a pass play breaks down. Counted over his games this season.
- Scrambles / game
- Times a game he drops back to pass and runs instead. Counted over his games this season.
- Dropbacks / game
- Times a game he drops back to pass, counting the plays that end in a sack or a scramble. It is his passing volume. Counted over his games this season.
- Designed runs inside the 10 / game
- Runs called for him inside the opponent’s 10-yard line: his short rushing touchdown chances. Counted over his games this season.
- Sacks per dropback
- The share of his dropbacks that end in a sack. Lower is better. Counted over his games this season.
- INT rate
- The share of his pass attempts that are intercepted. Lower is better. Counted over his games this season.
- aDOT
- Average depth of target: how far past the line of scrimmage the ball travels in the air, in yards, on the passes thrown to him. For a quarterback it is the same for the passes he throws. For a receiver, 12 or more is a downfield role and under 8 is short and steady.
- Opp pressure rate
- How often this week’s opponent pressures the quarterbacks it faces, averaged over its games this season. More pressure is a tougher matchup for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- Pressure faced
- How often he has been pressured on his dropbacks over his most recent games, up to four (the row says how many).
- High value touches / game
- His catches anywhere on the field plus his carries inside the opponent’s 10-yard line, per game: the touches that score the most fantasy points. Counted over his games this season.
- Red zone touches / game
- His carries and targets inside the opponent’s 20-yard line, per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Rush success rate
- The share of his carries that leave his team better placed to score than before the snap, judged on down, distance and field position. Counted over his games this season.
- Breakaway rate
- The share of his carries that go 20 yards or more: his big play upside. Counted over his games this season.
- Opp stuff rate
- The share of runs this week’s opponent stops at or behind the line of scrimmage. More stuffed runs is a tougher matchup for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- Opp yards per carry allowed
- Rushing yards this week’s opponent gives up per carry on designed runs this season. Higher is better for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- WOPR
- Weighted opportunity rating: 1.5 × his target share plus 0.7 × his air yards share. It rolls volume and depth into one number; above 0.6 is a lead receiver’s workload.
- Catch rate
- The share of his targets he catches. Counted over his games this season.
- Separation
- How far, in yards, he is from the nearest defender when the ball arrives, averaged over his most recent games, up to four (the row says how many). More is more open.
- YAC over expected
- Yards he gains after the catch compared with what a typical receiver gains on the same catches, averaged over his most recent games, up to four (the row says how many). Above zero means he adds yards on his own.
- Opp deep targets allowed / game
- Passes thrown 20+ yards downfield against this week’s opponent per game. More is better for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- Opp catch rate allowed
- The share of targets against this week’s opponent that are caught. A higher rate is better for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- Usage worth vs scored
- What his carries and targets this season are worth per game at league average efficiency (each one valued by where on the field it came and, for a target, how deep), beside the fantasy points he has actually scored per game. Scoring well above his usage often comes back down; well below it often catches up.
- FG attempts / game
- Field goal attempts per game: a kicker’s volume. Counted over his games this season (last season only when he has none yet).
- 50+ makes / game
- Field goals made from 50 yards or longer per game. Most leagues give bonus points for them.
- FG make rate
- The share of his field goal attempts he makes, at every distance together.
- Red zone FG rate
- Field goal attempts per trip his offense makes inside the opponent’s 20-yard line. Drives that stall there end in short field goal tries, which feed a kicker.
- Weather
- The forecast for his game. A kicker always gets it, since wind and rain cut make rates and a dome takes the weather out. For anyone else it appears only when wind, rain or cold is strong enough to matter.
- Sacks / game
- Sacks this defense makes per game. Counted over its games this season (last season only when it has none yet).
- Takeaways / game
- Interceptions plus fumble recoveries this defense makes per game. Counted over its games this season (last season only when it has none yet).
- Pressure rate
- How often the quarterbacks this defense faced were pressured, averaged over its games this season.
- Opp expected points
- The points the offense this defense faces is expected to score this week. Lower is better for a defense.
- Opp giveaways / game
- Interceptions thrown plus fumbles lost per game by the offense this defense faces, this season.
- Opp sacks allowed per dropback
- The share of the opposing offense’s dropbacks that end in a sack, this season. Higher is better for a defense.
- Opposing QB
- The quarterback listed first on the opponent’s depth chart this week, with his injury report status. A backup starting is the biggest swing for a defense.
- Home / away
- Whether this defense plays at home this week.
- Carries / game
- His rushing attempts per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Touches / game
- His carries plus catches per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Targets / game
- Passes thrown his way per game, caught or not. A throw wiped out by a penalty does not count. Counted over his games this season.
- Yards per carry
- His rushing yards divided by his carries. Counted over his games this season.
- Opp pace
- How many offensive plays this week’s opponent runs per game, shown as fast, average or slow among the 32 teams. A fast opponent tends to mean more plays, and more chances, in the game.
- Roof / surface
- Whether his game is played outdoors, under a fixed roof or under a retractable one, and on grass or turf.
- Rest / schedule
- How much rest his team has had since its previous game: a short week after a Thursday game, a normal week, or extra rest after a bye.
- Starting QB
- The quarterback expected to start for his team this week, with his injury report status. A back’s or receiver’s week leans on who is throwing to him.
- Backfield role
- His role in his team’s backfield this week, after removing backs who are out: Lead, Committee or Backup. When an injury changed it, the reason shows beside it.
- Pass attempts / game
- Passes he throws per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Yards per attempt
- His passing yards divided by his pass attempts. Counted over his games this season.
- Pass TD rate
- The share of his pass attempts that go for a touchdown. Counted over his games this season.
- Rush attempts / game
- His runs per game, designed runs and scrambles together. Counted over his games this season.
- Rush yards / game
- His rushing yards per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Opp sacks / game
- Sacks this week’s opponent makes per game this season. More sacks means a tougher day for a quarterback.
- Opp takeaways / game
- Interceptions plus fumble recoveries this week’s opponent makes per game this season.
- Goal line carries / game
- His carries inside the opponent’s 5-yard line per game: his short touchdown chances. Counted over his games this season.
- Red zone carries / game
- His carries inside the opponent’s 20-yard line per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Red zone targets / game
- Passes thrown his way inside the opponent’s 20-yard line per game. Counted over his games this season.
- Opp rush yds allowed
- Rushing yards this week’s opponent gives up per game. More is better for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- Opp pass yds allowed
- Passing yards this week’s opponent gives up per game. More is better for him. Its rank among the 32 defenses shows as soft, average or tough for him.
- Games since injury
- How many games he has played since returning from an injury absence. 0 means he has not played since he was last out.
- Opp defender out
- The first defender on this week’s opponent who is listed Out, if any.
Compare your players
Open Sit or Start to compare your own players, or browse this week's close calls by position: quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, tight ends, kickers and defenses.